No answer in time: an instant payment that timed out
Trigger: No confirmation arrives within the scheme's time limit after Bank Alfa sends the instant payment.
What operations sees first: The customer is still looking at a spinner; the operations dashboard shows an outbound pacs.008 with no final status inside the expected few seconds.
WHERE IS THE MONEY?
Reserved on the debtor's account during the attempt, then released; no money left the bank.
DID SETTLEMENT HAPPEN?
Never became final — any funds positioned for the attempt were released when the timeout was declared.
WHO ACTS NEXT?
Nordbank or the instant CSM — whichever let the clock run out (AB05 versus AB06 says which) The customer retries. If timeouts cluster on one counterparty or one time window, operations raises it with the CSM or the beneficiary bank.
PLAY THE EXCEPTION
Trigger: The beneficiary side does not answer inside the scheme's time limit, so the payment cannot complete.
The debtor initiates an instant payment
Debtor (payer) → Bank Alfa (debtor agent)
The customer pays from an app or channel. From this moment the scheme's clock is running — the whole journey must finish within the scheme's time limit.
Step 1 of 7: The debtor initiates an instant payment
- 02ProcessingBank Alfa validates in real timeBank Alfa (debtor agent)
- 03PostingThe debtor's funds are reservedBank Alfa (debtor agent)
- 05 · EXCEPTION PATHProcessingThe CSM treats the payment as failedInstant CSM (e.g. TIPS-style)
- 07 · EXCEPTION PATHPostingThe reservation is releasedBank Alfa (debtor agent)
- OUTCOME
- Funds
- Never left the debtor's account — the reservation was released.
- Settlement
- No settlement occurred; instant schemes settle only on a positive answer.
- Who acts next
- Instant CSM (e.g. TIPS-style) — The debtor may simply retry; operations monitors whether one participant times out repeatedly.
Full step-by-step text (works without JavaScript)
- 02ProcessingBank Alfa validates in real timeBank Alfa (debtor agent)
Format checks, balance check, and sanctions screening all happen in seconds. Anything slow here burns the scheme's time budget.
Screening checkpoint: Real-time transaction screening — Instant rails force screening to be fast and highly automated — there is no batch window to hide latency in.
- 03PostingThe debtor's funds are reservedBank Alfa (debtor agent)
Bank Alfa earmarks the amount. The final debit is confirmed only when the beneficiary bank accepts — instant payments are all-or-nothing.
- RESERVE Debtor's current account at Bank Alfa — EUR 480.00
- 05 · EXCEPTION PATHProcessingThe CSM treats the payment as failedInstant CSM (e.g. TIPS-style)
Instant schemes are all-or-nothing: with no positive answer in time, the transfer must not settle. An unanswered payment is resolved as a failure, never left hanging.
- 07 · EXCEPTION PATHPostingThe reservation is releasedBank Alfa (debtor agent)
The debtor's money never left — the earmark is simply removed and the customer is told the payment failed.
- RELEASE Debtor's current account at Bank Alfa — EUR 480.00
- OUTCOME
- Funds
- Never left the debtor's account — the reservation was released.
- Settlement
- No settlement occurred; instant schemes settle only on a positive answer.
- Who acts next
- Instant CSM (e.g. TIPS-style) — The debtor may simply retry; operations monitors whether one participant times out repeatedly.
THE TIMELINE
- 01DebtorInitiates an instant transfer; Bank Alfa validates the instruction and places a reservation on the account.
- 02Bank AlfaSends the transfer into the instant CSM, which starts the scheme's execution clock.pacs.008
- 03Instant CSMNo positive confirmation is received within the time limit — the transaction must fail rather than hang.
In an instant scheme, 'no answer' is itself an outcome: the rulebook defines a hard time limit so payments end with certainty.
- 04Instant CSMA negative status report travels back to Bank Alfa reporting the timeout — reason code AB05 when the creditor agent timed out, AB06 when the CSM or another instructed agent did.pacs.002
- 05Bank AlfaReleases the reservation on the debtor's account and shows the customer a clear failure so they can retry.
Resolution: The payment fails definitively rather than hanging in an ambiguous state. The reservation is released, and a retry a moment later often succeeds if the beneficiary side had a transient problem.
Sources for this scenario2
- Scheme-specific rule2025 version 1.1 (EPC004-16)
2025 SEPA Instant Credit Transfer rulebook ↗ — European Payments Council · timeout handling
Version 1.1 replaced version 1.0 at publication on 5 October 2025 and is stated to remain in effect up to 21 November 2027. The EPC states it is compliant with Regulation (EU) 2024/886, the Instant Payments Regulation.
- Simplified educational illustration
Payments Signal editorial teaching models — Payments Signal
What this simplifies: Single-CSM model; institution-specific handling varies.
Used wherever diagrams, scenarios, figures, or example values are didactic constructions rather than sourced facts; every such use carries a simplifications disclosure. All people, companies, banks, and list entries in examples are fictional.